Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Preservationists fear loss of federal tax credit program

The former Sibley building on East Main St. in Rochester
Emily Hunt for WXXI News
The former Sibley building on East Main St. in Rochester

The latest tax reform bills from Republican leaders in the House and Senate do not include a popular program that has helped subsidize the renovation of numerous historic buildings in Rochester and other upstate cities in the past 30 years.

The historic preservation tax credit program provides a 20 percent federal tax credit for the rehabilitation of historic, income producing buildings.

Wayne Goodman, executive director of the Landmark Society of Western New York, says the loss of this incentive would be devastating to developers, preservationists, and communities.

"It certainly would be a major setback, especially in Rochester with so much momentum that we have been experiencing in our downtown and in our neighborhoods, probably within the last seven or eight years, especially."

One recent downtown Rochester development project that has benefited from the historic tax credit is Sibley Square.  But Goodman said it's a myth that these tax incentives just make rich developers richer.

"Usually, these are with projects that have such an incredibly high construction budget that tax credits really push a project along that has razor thin margins. It's not uncommon for investors to see profits for many, many years after project completion."

Many projects utilizing the tax incentive don't even involve private developers, Goodman said. He pointed to the renovation of the Holy Rosary campus on Lexington Avenue as one example. 

The former school, convent, and rectory is now housing complex with apartments and single family homes. Whether a development is led by a for-profit or non-profit entity, a project investment must exceed the base value of the original property in order to quality for the tax credit.

Goodman said many members of the New York Congressional delegation have been very supportive of the program.

When asked whether he supports the historic tax credit, Congressman Tom Reed, through a spokesperson, sent WXXI News the following statement .“The historic tax credit is important to our communities and is responsible for revitalizing many of our aging buildings. This helps working families and seniors throughout our region. As we move forward with comprehensive tax reform, I will continue to fight for tax policies, such as these credits, that have a positive impact throughout New York.”