Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Developers eye Tent City revival, look to start construction a year after devastating fire

The historic Tent City building complex at Lyell and Dewey avenues was being demolished on Friday, Aug.1, 2025, after being destroyed by fire overnight. The building caught fire late Thursday, and by morning the city determined the entire six-building complex was structurally compromised an needed to be torn down.
Veronica Volk
/
WXXI News
The historic Tent City building complex at Lyell and Dewey avenues was being demolished on Friday, Aug.1, 2025, after being destroyed by fire overnight. The building caught fire late Thursday, and by morning the city determined the entire six-building complex was structurally compromised an needed to be torn down.

Rebuilding of the former Tent City property could begin in late summer — one year after a fire largely destroyed the historic complex off Dewey and Lyell avenues.

The section that was saved will be preserved and restored, developers said, and the rest built new.

Developers resubmitted the project for site plan review earlier this month. Plans for what’s being called Gardner's Lofts mostly replicates prior designs for the site.

“As you know, this project was previously approved, and construction was ready to begin when a fire destroyed a large portion of the buildings,” Matt Tomlinson, a partner at Marathon Engineering, wrote in a letter to the city.

An rendering of the rebuilt Gardner's Lofts shows new brick masonry and high density fiber cement cladding along Dewey Avenue and the rebuild Lyell Avenue face of the building to the left. The portion of the building not destroyed in the 2025 fire is shown at the far right.
Provided image
/
The Architectural Team
A rendering of the rebuilt Gardner's Lofts, formerly Tent City complex, shows a building façade consisting of new brick masonry and high density fiber cement cladding along Dewey Avenue and the rebuild Lyell Avenue face of the building on the far left. The portion of the building not destroyed in the 2025 fire is shown at the far right.

Developer WinnCompanies is proposing 88 apartments priced for extremely low- to low-income individuals and families, with a supportive housing set-aside for veterans, including those transitioning from homelessness.

Plans were to repurpose what was a series of six interconnected buildings. But only the three smallest buildings, located at the north edge of the complex, survived the fire. The new construction is shown as a mix of brick and cement cladding, with rectangular instead of arched windows.

Gov. Kathy Hochul had committed $46 million in tax credits and other assistance to the project a month before the Aug. 1 fire. That funding remains intact, officials said. The earlier plan carried a $72 million price tag. An updated cost figure was not immediately available.

The cause of the fire remains under investigation.

The historic Tent City building complex at Lyell and Dewey avenues was being demolished on Friday, Aug.1, 2025, after being destroyed by fire overnight. The building caught fire late Thursday, and by morning the city determined the entire six-building complex was structurally compromised an needed to be torn down.
Max Schulte
/
WXXI News
The historic Tent City building complex at Lyell and Dewey avenues was being demolished on Friday, Aug.1, 2025, after being destroyed by fire overnight. The building caught fire late Thursday, and by morning the city determined the entire six-building complex was structurally compromised an needed to be torn down.

In addition to apartments, the rebuilt complex will have 6,400 square feet of retail and commercial space. An outdoor “amenity area” will include a memorial, a flagpole, an eternal flame and seating along with a grill/outdoor kitchen area.

"The new development proposal for Gardner's Lofts largely replicates the design of our prior plan for the site,” said company spokesman Ed Cafasso – adding that the “significant, obvious difference” is this is no longer just an adaptive reuse but an integrated preservation and new construction project.

Brian Sharp is WXXI's investigations and enterprise editor. He also reports on business and development in the area. He has been covering Rochester since 2005. His journalism career spans nearly three decades.