WXXI AM News

Governor has the upper hand in a late budget

Mar 22, 2019

The new state budget, due April 1, will be first one decided by an all-Democratic state legislature in a decade, after Republicans ruled the Senate for most of the past century. And while the leadership of the Senate and Assembly have been newly reasserting their governing powers when it comes to the spending plan, there’s only so far that they can go in their disagreements with Governor Andrew Cuomo.  

The Speaker of the State Assembly, Carl Heastie, and the Senate Leader, Andrea Stewart-Cousins, in just a few short months have formed a close working relationship. They often hold joint events together, where they announce agreement on major pieces of legislation. Before a press conference on March 19, announcing an agreement on installing speed cameras at schools in New York City and Buffalo, they engaged in friendly banter about who had the most party members with them in front of the podium.

“You win the member count today,” Stewart-Cousins, told Heastie.

“We probably always will,” Heastie quipped in reply.

“Oh no,” Stewart-Cousins replied, with a laugh.  “But you’re probably right.”

In the first ten weeks of the session, they’ve acted to strengthen abortion rights and transgender rights,   allowed children of undocumented immigrants to receive college aid, and passed gun control measures. In many cases, Cuomo, who also backed those measures, has struggled to keep up, his role reduced to signing the bills afterwards. 

Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, who is so pleased about the changes that he referred to himself and the Senate Leader as the "wonder twins" in a New York Times story, says there is a new way of doing business in Albany.

“There’s a new dynamic,” said Heastie. “A Democratic Assembly, a Democratic Senate. I think this is the first experience for him.”

For the first eight years that Cuomo was governor there was a divided government with Republicans leading the State Senate.

Friction between the newly unified legislature and Governor Cuomo has come out in the open during the budget process.

The two houses are in tandem on many spending priorities, and they released very similar budget resolutions. Both want to spend more money on schools than the governor wants - around $600 million more than the $1 billion increase proposed by the Cuomo. The governor’s budget director says the leglistive budgets raise spending by as much as $3.5 billion, something he says is unacceptable. The governor’s chief of staff has called the Senate and Assembly budgets “fantasyland”.

Cuomo has been disparaging toward the Democrats, saying the Assembly is too beholden to the teachers unions, and that the Senate Democrats are too inexperienced to make good governing decisions.

“Now you have to govern as opposed to just doing a bumper sticker political slogan,” Cuomo said on March 12 on WAMC.

Speaker Heastie says the comments are unnecessary.

“Disparaging comments aren’t helpful,” Heastie said.

Senate Leader Stewart-Cousins says she spoke to the governor about her displeasure with his statements.

“I questioned, obviously, why there was a constant criticism,” said Stewart-Cousins. “The governor and I have spoken and we are planning to move forward.”

Since then the governor has not repeated his comments.   

But the Democrats in the legislature may find their ability to move ahead on bills without the governor curbed when it comes to the state budget.

Once the budget goes beyond April 1 without a deal, the governor can present a spending extender - and add all of the policy items he likes in it, for example his version of items like legalizing adult recreational marijuana. The legislature has just two choices -  pass it with no amendments, or reject it, and the government will shut down. Cuomo has said if that happens, the legislature will take the blame.

The governor’s ability to present a take-it-or-leave-it budget stems from a decision by the state’s highest court. It was brought by then-Speaker of the Assembly, Sheldon Silver, against former Governor George Pataki. The court sided with Pataki, and said a governor can put unrelated policy items into the budget, and the legislature has no power to alter them.

Speaker Heastie, who is Silver’s successor says he’s fully aware of that.

“Once you go past the March 31 deadline, it increase the governor’s power,” he said.

Another potential incentive is the future of a pay raise for lawmakers. A commission granted them their first salary increase in 20 years, but said it was contingent on the budget being passed on time. Lawmakers say that rule, which is being challenged in court, does not affect their decisions.