No plans yet to fix future budget deficits for New York
As the nation’s economic uncertainty continues with a volatile stock market, higher gas prices and inflation, New York state’s budget forecast has also suffered a reversal of fortune.
When Gov. Kathy Hochul and the Legislature agreed on a state budget in April, they said the spending plan would be in balance for the next several years.
It was an unusually rosy outlook in a state where financial fortunes rise and fall with the ups and downs of the stock market. About one-fifth of all tax collections are tied to the financial industry, including income taxes on the annual Wall Street bonuses and the capital gains tax.
Just a little over three months later, on a hot summer evening, the governor’s budget division released a new economic forecast.
It greatly reduced expected collection projections from personal income taxes and cut job growth estimates in half for 2023, from 1.5% to 0.8%. It cited the highest inflation rate in 40 years, at 9.1% in June 2022, and noted that every major stock index is down by more than 10% since the beginning of the year. The NASDAQ, based in New York City, is down 23%.
As a result, projected budget deficits are back, beginning in 2023, with a $310 million gap for the next fiscal year. It’s expected to balloon to $6.2 billion by 2027, if the current rate of state spending continues.
"Like the rest of the country," Hochul said in a statement, "New York State is facing substantial headwinds with a changing national economy, and our latest update to the Enacted Budget Financial Plan reflects that."
Patrick Orecki with the fiscal watchdog group Citizens Budget Commission said it’s one of the most rapid reversals he’s seen.
“What we saw, in the first-quarter update, was a change of the script going forward,” he said.
Orecki said the budget division’s projections in April reflected the economy at the time, and the outlook was very positive. But he said some of the spending plan’s foundations were already shaky and relied significantly on one-shot revenues.
An example of one of those costs is a pandemic-related federal grant that provides over $800 million for 1 million additional New Yorkers to enroll in Medicaid. That aid is ending, but Hochul has not yet ended the pandemic state of emergency declaration, so the state will have to pick up the tab for those costs.
Orecki credited the budget office for coming clean on the impending shortfalls, but he said it would be smart to take some steps now to avoid future deficits. He says state spending growth is much higher than in previous years, at about 12%, compared to roughly 3% to 4% per year in the past decade.
“Spending growth is well above trend,” he said. “So they need to start thinking about where there are cost-saving opportunities.”
One contributor to the spending increase is Hochul’s plan to pump $10 billion into the state’s health care workforce over the next five years.
On Aug. 3, Hochul distributed some of that money when she announced the first phase of a bonus pay program for health care and mental health care workers. Hochul said those workers went through a lot during the pandemic, and are “overworked and underpaid.” She said it’s also in New York’s interest to retain them.
“It’s not just a crisis for these workers,” Hochul said. “It’s a crisis for all of us who really do need that health care, as well.”
Orecki said the health care workforce spending would be easier to reduce because not all of the money has been committed yet.
He said health care represents the biggest part of the budget, followed by spending on schools and the state’s workforce.
“Two out of every three dollars you spend is in those programs,” Orecki said.
Orecki said Hochul and her budget staff should not, however, follow some past practices for a quick fix. They include actions by former Gov. Andrew Cuomo.
Cuomo had promised to limit state spending growth to 2% per year. One of his approaches to try to fulfill that was delaying some large Medicaid payments owed to providers from one fiscal year to the next. That way, the spending growth would appear to be more limited than it actually was.
Orecki said there is one element in future spending plans that he’d like to see stay the same: the commitment to put more money into the state’s rainy-day fund.
The plan calls for depositing $15.4 billion into reserve funds over the next four years, bringing the total to $19.4 billion.
Shams Tarek, a spokesman for the Division of the Budget, said, “there are no changes to Enacted Budget programs currently planned.”